Meta Faces Massive Fine in Italy
Italy has imposed a staggering €805 million (approximately $887 million) penalty on Meta for accessing Android users’ photo and video galleries on Facebook without obtaining explicit consent. The fine stems from a default-enabled feature called “Get suggestions from gallery while browsing Facebook,” which allowed Meta to utilize personal media files without users’ clear permission. Italy’s data protection authority ruled this practice violates the European ePrivacy Directive, incorporated into Italian law, which mandates free and informed consent before accessing smartphone data.
The Italian regulators gave Meta 60 days to deactivate this intrusive feature and secure separate user approval for its use going forward. With around 20 million Android users in Italy, the sanction targets Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. Meta challenges Italy’s jurisdiction, arguing that the case should be handled in Ireland, but Italian officials maintain the ePrivacy Directive doesn’t allow transferring such cases. The fine represents roughly 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue.
Legal Battles Mount for Meta
The Italian authority also criticized Meta for its lack of cooperation during the investigation, leading to the hefty fine. The company is required to disable the default setting even for users who had previously consented. Meta plans to appeal the ruling.
Meanwhile, Meta is also facing a potential $25 billion penalty in New Mexico related to the Cambridge Analytica scandal involving privacy violations. The court held Meta accountable for deceptive practices linked to the 2016 U.S. presidential election data breach. Jurors found 43 million violations of New Mexico’s consumer protection law, with prosecutors seeking the maximum $5,000 fine per violation, potentially totaling $215 billion. Meta’s lawyers argue the company should only owe $3.4 billion after the verdict.
These developments highlight the increasing regulatory scrutiny tech giants like Meta face regarding user privacy and data protection. The fines in Italy and New Mexico underscore the critical importance of safeguarding consumer rights in the digital age and could significantly impact Meta’s business operations. Given the ongoing legal pressures, Meta will likely need to overhaul its data handling policies to prevent similar issues in the future.
The recent €805 million fine imposed on Meta by Italy highlights the growing scrutiny over the company's data practices. This comes on the heels of another significant legal challenge where Meta faces a potential $25 billion penalty in New Mexico due to privacy violations linked to the 2016 Facebook data breach. For more details on this unfolding situation, you can read about the court's ruling in New Mexico.