Italian Court’s Ruling on Valeria’s Case
An Italian court in Rome has mandated the urgent return of 12-year-old Ukrainian Valeria to her father in Ukraine, despite the ongoing martial law in the country. Valeria had been under the temporary care of the family of Andrea Quercia, mayor of Ceccano, and will finally reunite with her father, Nazar, after a separation lasting a year and a half. Nazar was unable to leave Ukraine due to the war conditions.
The process of arranging Valeria’s return required over six months of close cooperation between Ukrainian authorities and their Italian counterparts. This cooperation ensured Nazar could attend the court hearing in person. The office of Ukrainian Ombudsman Dmytro Lubinets played an active role in facilitating Nazar’s trip to Rome. A panel of four judges from the juvenile court in Rome issued the unprecedented decision to prioritize Valeria’s immediate return, setting a legal precedent during Ukraine’s martial law period.
'This is the first time an Italian court has ruled on the return of a child amidst martial law. Typically, during Ukraine’s martial law, foreign nations do not return children left abroad without parental care. This is a landmark case,' Dmytro Lubinets
The reunion between Valeria and her father was deeply emotional, with the girl rushing into his arms, both shedding tears along with others present in the courtroom.
Context on Child Deportations in Ukraine
As of September 25th, Ukraine has officially documented 20,651 cases of child deportations and forced relocations. Approximately 1.6 million children living in temporarily occupied Ukrainian territories face state-driven indoctrination and militarization efforts, including at least 582,600 school-aged children. Ukraine has successfully secured the return of 2,644 children, among them 34 reunited with their families through efforts supported by former U.S. First Lady Melania Trump.
An independent UN commission has classified the deportation and forced transfer of Ukrainian children by Russia as war crimes and crimes against humanity. On November 12th, the European Parliament adopted a resolution demanding the return of deported and forcibly relocated Ukrainian children by Russia, calling for an end to their russification, indoctrination, and militarization.
'The family is finally reunited. Ahead lies a long journey of reintegration for Valeria after such a prolonged separation from her father and home. We await them at home,' Dmytro Lubinets
This ruling highlights not only the hardships faced by families torn apart by war but also the potential for legal protection for children caught in complex situations. Valeria’s return may serve as a model for similar cases where children left without guardians can be reunited with their parents, even amid armed conflict. Such cases could become crucial precedents for the international community concerning child rights protection in crisis environments.
The emotional reunion of Valeria and her father highlights the ongoing challenges faced by families affected by the war in Ukraine. As international efforts continue to secure the return of children, recent developments, such as Melania Trump’s involvement in repatriating children from Russia, emphasize the importance of collaborative efforts in addressing the plight of displaced families. Understanding these initiatives sheds light on the broader context of child repatriation amidst ongoing conflicts.